Rakesh Saha, the Chief Financial Officer (CFO) of Sunrise Industries, a prominent manufacturing firm in Mumbai, was under immense pressure to achieve the company's financial objectives. The Board of Directors had establi
CS Professional · Internal and Forensic Audit · PYQS · June 2025
Rakesh Saha, the Chief Financial Officer (CFO) of Sunrise Industries, a prominent manufacturing firm in Mumbai, was under immense pressure to achieve the company's financial objectives. The Board of Directors had established aggressive targets, and Rakesh knew that his annual performance review and substantial bonuses hinged on meeting these goals. While reviewing the company's accounts during a routine internal audit, Rakesh identified a weakness in the oversight of travel and expense reimbursements. Seizing this vulnerability, he saw a chance to artificially boost the company's profits by altering the financial records. Rakesh justified his actions to himself, believing that the prosperity of Sunrise Industries would ultimately benefit its employees and stakeholders, outweighing any temporary ethical lapse. He viewed this manipulation as a short-term solution, intending to rectify the figures in the subsequent quarter once the company regained financial stability. Fraud is always driven by an underlying motive. When an opportunity to perpetrate fraud arises, the individual rationalizes the wrongdoing in a manner that aligns with their personal moral framework. Explain this statement in the context of the scenario above.
Answer & Explanation:
Fraud Triangle Overview: Developed by Dr. Donald Ray Cressey from his Ph.D. research on embezzlers ("trust violators"). Based on interviews with 133 imprisoned individuals who misused trusted positions (published in Other People's Money). Excludes habitual offenders; focuses on trusted persons turning to fraud. Hypothesis: Fraud occurs when a trusted person faces a non-shareable financial problem, sees a secret solution via abuse of trust, and justifies it to align with their self-image. Known as the Fraud Triangle: Pressure, Opportunity, Rationalization. Application to Rakesh Saha's Case: Pressure (Motive): Faced intense board expectations to meet aggressive financial targets at Sunrise Industries. Performance evaluation and bonuses tied to success, creating a personal, non-shareable financial strain. Opportunity (Ability): Identified a weakness in internal controls over travel and expense reimbursements during an audit. Allowed discreet manipulation of financial records to inflate profits. Rationalization (Justification): Convinced himself the fraud was a temporary fix benefiting all employees and stakeholders. Believed he could correct the figures next quarter, aligning the act with his moral compass as a short-term necessity. Explanation of the Statement: Fraud requires a motive (Pressure: Rakesh's need to meet targets). An opportunity enables it (Opportunity: weak controls). The fraudster justifies it internally (Rationalization: Rakesh's belief in collective benefit and reversibility). Rakesh's case shows how these elements converge, allowing a trusted person to violate trust while preserving self-image.
Topics: Forensic Audit
Related Questions in this Topic
- As per Association of Certified Fraud Examiners (ACFE) 2022 report 85% of all fraudsters displayed at least one behaviou...
- The Bhartiya Sakshya Adhiniyam play an important role in determining the admissibility and weight of evidence in case in...
- A reckless waste of firm's assets by speculating on the stock market and incompetence/ negligence in managing business o...
- In forensic auditing, specific procedures are carried out in order to produce evidence. Investigator uses various techni...
- Briefly explain Corruption, Asset Misappropriation and Financial Statement Fraud in brief.