M/s Speed Airways Pvt Ltd. a borrower, filed a case before a civil court that Diligent Bank, a secured creditor, has not issued any letter to the company for demanding of repayment of loan and stating its intention to en
CS Professional · Corporate Restructuring, Valuation and Insolvency · PYQS · June 2018
M/s Speed Airways Pvt Ltd. a borrower, filed a case before a civil court that Diligent Bank, a secured creditor, has not issued any letter to the company for demanding of repayment of loan and stating its intention to enforce the secured interest. Rather, fraudulently transferred the funds from its account to another company only to classify it as NPA as per the provisions of SARFAESI Act, 2002. In the light of the decided case, state whether the case is maintainable.
Answer & Explanation:
The facts of present case are similar to case of M/s Golf Technologies (P). Ltd. & Anr v. Axis Bank Ltd. & Ors (Del) where the issue was that the company stated that the letter dated 31st December, 2012 was not issued and that it was fraudulently created by the bank, hence the transfer of monies from the plaintiffs' account to M/s Tulip Telecom Limited was wrong and the said amount was depleted from their account only to classify it as an NPA. This according to the plaintiff amounts to fraud and would form the basis of the maintainability of the present suit. The ground alleged in the suit is fraud by the bank played upon the plaintiff. Suit was dismissed on the ground that civil court has no jurisdiction to decide the case which Debt Recovery Tribunal has power except in case of fraud. Court was of the view that the ground of fraud raised by the plaintiff can be duly addressed in proceedings under Section 17 of the Act. Accordingly, the case of M/s Speed Airways Pvt. Ltd. will not be maintainable in the court. It can approach Debt Recovery Tribunal.
Topics: Insolvency
Related Questions in this Topic
- UNCITRAL Model Law is binding on member countries but at the best obiter dicta for Courts of the member countries dealin...
- Progress of enforcement of Insolvency and Bankruptcy Code, 2016 depends on four pillars apart from the adjudicating auth...
- "Banks and financial institutions do have free hands to take possession of assets of a defaulting debtor under Securitie...
- Unlike Companies Act, 1956 winding up can be resorted to only when resolution plan either could not be finalised or fail...
- "More and more banks are embarking on forming of Asset Reconstruction Companies such that they can manage their risks be...