Anustup Chandra Heavy Electricals Ltd., is a major player in the league of manufacture of heavy industrial boilers and steam turbine. The company had won a major bid for a big project in Colombo for fabrication of 10,000
CS Professional · Forensic Audit · PYQS · June 2019
Anustup Chandra Heavy Electricals Ltd., is a major player in the league of manufacture of heavy industrial boilers and steam turbine. The company had won a major bid for a big project in Colombo for fabrication of 10,000 MW boiler and turbine. The company outsourced some of the activities through a system of open tender and awarded contracts to eight different companies. The company received complaints from three different bidders that there was a collusive bidding by four entities, to whom different contracts had been awarded by the company. You are appointed to conduct forensic audit to determine whether the complaint made by the three different bidders is having any merit. Your approach be based on: What will be your line of investigation, to determine whether there has been really any collusive bidding?
Answer & Explanation:
The line of investigation after looking into the indicators/red flags shall consist of:- Prepare a questionnaire for interviewing the complainants and those who failed but rated good and conduct interview of the complainants and investigate through confidential sources. Data collection paper trail: bid documents, requests for bids, bid comparison documents prepared internally, Bill of Quantities (BoQs), comparison line item wise and bid securities. Identify physical similarities in the bid documents like paper quality, colour schemes, type, faces, formatting, language, etc. Connection between bidders on inter-company connections, common address, contacts details, etc. Unusual bidding patterns comparing the financial and quantity data line item wise. Test whether they are exact percentages or value apart. Conduct a physical verification check of the addresses given by the bidders in question to see whether they are operating from same building or not. Background check on the final shortlisted bidders for finding out common ownership, employees, affiliations or prior involvement in the other collusive bidding schemes. Review the bid security details in order to identify whether issued by same bank and branch to group of bidders and/or issued to bidder by the same day in all the cases. Most bid documents have a special enquiry / audit enabler clause. Exercising that right on the winning bidder is conducted as a routine formality. Instead, a detailed inquiry can be made into the business of the winning bidder. Interviewing the winning bidder based on the information collected and from the above processes and as given by them in bid documents. Also have interview of the three complainants and all of the other bidders who have lost the bid to find out the reasons of their failure.
Topics: Forensic Audit
Related Questions in this Topic
- Vishnu Polymers Ltd., has got complaints from three anonymous persons which were found placed inside the employee's comp...
- Vishnu Polymers Ltd., has got complaints from three anonymous persons which were found placed inside the employee's comp...
- In a college, the cashier has been accused of embezzling fees collections. After the conclusion of forensic audit, the F...
- In a college, the cashier has been accused of embezzling fees collections. After the conclusion of forensic audit, the F...
- In a college, the cashier has been accused of embezzling fees collections. After the conclusion of forensic audit, the F...