Everest Manufacturing Industrial Limited started 4 years ago, is expected to grow at a higher rate of 4 years in the coming years and thereafter the growth rate will fall and stabilize at a lower level. The following inf
CS Professional · Valuations & Business Modelling · PYQS · December 2019
Everest Manufacturing Industrial Limited started 4 years ago, is expected to grow at a higher rate of 4 years in the coming years and thereafter the growth rate will fall and stabilize at a lower level. The following information has been made available to you for your analysis: Base Year (Year 0) Information (In Million ₹) Revenues 3000 Million EBIT 500 Million Capital Expenditure 350 Million Depreciation 250 Million Net Working Capital as a percentage of EBIT 25% Corporate tax rate (for all scenarios) 30% Paid-up Equity Capital (10 Face Value) 400 Million Market value of debt 1200 Million Inputs for the High Growth Phase Length of high growth phase 4 years Growth rate in revenues, depreciation 20% Net Working Capital as a percentage of EBIT 25% Cost of debt (pre-tax) 13% Debt-equity ratio 1:1 Risk-free rate 11% Market risk premium 7% Equity Beta 1.129 Inputs for the Stable Growth Phase Expected growth rate in revenues and EBIT 10% Capital expenditure are offset by depreciation Net Working Capital as a percentage of EBIT 25% Cost of debt (pre-tax) 12.14% Risk-free rate 10% Market risk premium 6% Equity Beta 1.0 Debt-equity ratio 2:3 With above information background, answer the following questions of the Management: Comparing the given case, discuss on the advantages and disadvantages of the Dividend Discount Models.
Answer & Explanation:
Dividend Discount Model It is a way of valuing a company based on the theory that a stock is worth the discounted sum of all of its future dividend payments. In other words, it is used to evaluate stocks based on the net present value of the future dividends. Financial theory states that the value of a stock is the worth all of the future cash flows expected to be generated by the firm discounted by an appropriate risk-adjusted rate. We can use dividends as a measure of the cash flows returned to the shareholder. Some examples of regular dividend paying companies are TCS, Infosys, Coal India etc. We can use Dividend Discount Model to value these companies. The dividend discount model (DDM) seeks to estimate the current value of a given stock on the basis of the spread between projected dividend growth and the associated discount rate. The DDM calculates this present value in the following manner: Present Stock Value = Dividend Share / (R Discount - R Dividend Growth ) In the DDM, a present stock value that is higher than a stock's market value indicates that the stock is undervalued and that it is a good time to purchase shares. Advantages There are three major reasons why the dividend discount model is a popular valuation technique: Simplicity of Calculations Once investors know the variables of the model, calculating the value of a share of stock is very straightforward. It only takes a little of algebra to calculate the price of stock. Sound and Logical Basis for the Model The model is based on the premise that investors purchase stocks so that they can get paid in the future. Even though there are a number of reasons that investors may purchase a security, this basis is correct. If investors never received a payment for their security it wouldn't be worth anything. The Process Can Be Reversed to Determine Growth Rates Experts Predicted After looking at the price of a share of stock, investors can rearrange the process to determine the dividend growth rates that are expected for the company. This is useful if they know the predicted value of a share of stock but want to know what the expected dividends are. Disadvantages Although many investors still use the model, it has become a lot less popular in recent years for a variety of reasons: Reflects Rationality, Not Reality: The dividend discount model is based on the concept that investors invest in stocks that are most likely to pay them the most. Although this is the way that investors should behave, it does not always reflect the way investors actually behave. Many investors purchase stocks for reasons that have nothing to do with the company's financial position or its future dividend payments. Some investors purchase a company that happens to be more glamorous or interesting. This often explains why there is a discrepancy between a stock's intrinsic value and the actual market value. Difficulty Determining the Variables that go into the Model: The dividend discount model is simple to use, however, it is difficult to determine the numbers that go into it, which can yield inaccurate results. Companies are often unpredictable with their dividends, so forecasting them for this model is difficult. It is also very difficult to estimate the future sales of a company, which influences a corporation's abilities to maintain or grow dividends. Dividends Aren't the Only Way Earnings Have Value to Investors: Investors may be primarily concerned with dividends, but all earnings are still owned by investors. Dividends only represent the share of earnings that a corporation chooses to payout. Retained earnings are still owed to investors and still count towards their wealth. This is why newer models evaluate the overall cash flow of a company, not the amount that is paid back to investors. Investor Bias: Investors have a tendency to confirm their own expectations. This means that most investors are going to come up with their own values for a stock since many of the inputs here are somewhat subjective. Only those who can force themselves to be objective are likely to find accurate variables for the model.
Topics: Valuation Models
Related Questions in this Topic
- State under what conditions/assumptions the following statements are true (state only one important condition/assumption...
- A banker is reviewing your proposal for grant of long term loan and working capital facilities. What are the key ratios ...
- Explain the concepts of percentage of sales method and regression analysis method in estimating working capital with the...
- Prepare cash flow statement from the table and information given below: Liabilities 31st March, 2000 31st March, 2...
- Explain the business model followed by Netflix.