"The opinion giver may also be requested to furnish an opinion on matters governed by the laws of some other country." Comment and discuss the reliance of the opinion of local counsel on foreign laws.

CS Professional · Drafting, Pleadings and Appearances · PYQS · June 2022
"The opinion giver may also be requested to furnish an opinion on matters governed by the laws of some other country." Comment and discuss the reliance of the opinion of local counsel on foreign laws.

Answer & Explanation:

Foreign Law and Reliance on Local Counsel The principal opinion giver for a party in a business transaction typically renders an opinion covering the laws of the state and applicable central laws and sets forth this limitation in the text of the opinion. The opinion giver may also be requested to furnish an opinion on matters governed by the laws of some other country. Unless the limited nature of the review of another jurisdiction's law is described in the opinion, the opinion giver will, in most instances, seek the advice and opinion of local counsel. An opinion giver should, however, always be cognizant of the fact that rendering an opinion based upon legal principles applicable in foreign jurisdictions exposes the opinion giver to liability for a negligent interpretation of that law. The retention of local counsel to furnish an opinion raises different questions with respect to the principal opinion giver's responsibility for the opinions expressed in the local lawyer's opinion. If the principal opinion giver renders an opinion on the same matters as the local lawyer, the opinion giver customarily expresses its reliance on the local counsel's opinion (an example of recommended language is included below) rather than simply restating the local counsel's opinion in the body of its opinion: In rendering the opinions expressed in paragraphs, and ............ we have relied [solely] on the opinion of ............ in so far as such opinions relate to the laws of ............ and we have made no independent examination of the laws of that jurisdiction. When expressly stating reliance on the opinion of local counsel, the principal opinion giver's sole responsibility is to exercise reasonable care in the selection of local counsel (if, in fact, the principal opinion giver selects such counsel). The opinion giver is not responsible for independently investigating or otherwise verifying the law of the foreign jurisdiction. The principal opinion giver may assume a broader responsibility to examine the statutory and case law of the foreign jurisdiction if the principal opinion giver's opinion letter states that the opinion giver "concurs" with the legal opinions provided in the opinion letter of local counsel or that the local counsel's opinion letter is satisfactory in substance. The preferred and more recent common practice is for the local counsel's opinion letter to be addressed to the recipient of the principal opinion letter (rather than to the principal opinion giver) and for the principal opinion giver not to render an opinion on that subject.

Topics: Legal Opinion

Open in Interactive Practice Hub · Full Practice Hub · Chapter Weightage · More in this subject

Related Questions in this Topic