ABC Ltd. was incorporated on May 12, 1986, under the Indian Companies Act, having its registered office at Mumbai, Maharashtra. The present capital structure of the petitioner company is as follows: ₹ 1,000 crore Authori
CS Professional · Corporate Restructuring, Valuation and Insolvency · PYQS · June 2024
ABC Ltd. was incorporated on May 12, 1986, under the Indian Companies Act, having its registered office at Mumbai, Maharashtra. The present capital structure of the petitioner company is as follows: ₹ 1,000 crore Authorised Capital-100 crore equity shares of ₹ 10 each. Issued Subscribed Capital and paid-up capital of ₹ 780 crore-78 crore equity shares of ₹ 10 each [includes equity shares represented by GDRs]. The company is having 4 business segments related to manufacturing of products L, M, N and O. Turnover of O product is around ₹ 1,300 crore. Asset of ABC Ltd are ₹ 2,700 crore out of which product O related asset are ₹ 1,400 crore. XYZ Ltd. is a company having its registered office at Surat, Gujrat. Authorised, issued and paid up capital of company is ₹ 750 crore having turnover of ₹ 820 crore. It is engaged in the business of manufacture and sale of product O. Assets of XYZ Ltd. are ₹ 1,500 crore. XYZ Ltd. already hold 14.98% of the equity shares of the ABC Ltd. acquired at ₹ 267 per share from Six ventures and got two directors in Board of Directors of ABC Ltd. XYZ Ltd. has made an open offer to shareholders of ABC Ltd at ₹ 190 per share to acquire controlling stake of ABC Ltd. ABC Ltd. Management opposed the open offer citing reasons of low price that was not beneficial to the shareholders of ABC Ltd. but in reality the management of ABC Ltd. had fear of losing control over the company. XYZ Ltd. had an eye on the Product O business of ABC Ltd. for a long time. The open offer was a step towards fulfilling the dream. Full control of product O business was ultimate purpose of XYZ Ltd. ABC Ltd. script was trading at ₹ 207.50 on the closing hours of trading at the Bombay Stock Exchange. After lot of fights and hassles, both companies came to truce. Pursuant to acquisitions through negotiated transactions, a proposal to demerge the ABC Ltd. company's Product O business into company TRM Ltd. and acquisition of 51% controlling stake in TRM Ltd. was given by XYZ Ltd. and after due deliberation, the Board of Directors of the ABC Ltd company accepted the proposal for demerger of the Product O business into TRM Ltd. and subsequent acquisition of 51% stake in same by XYZ Ltd. After demerger TRM Ltd. will have around 35% market share of product O business on pan India basis. ABC Ltd. Employees Welfare Foundation is an employee welfare trust established under the Indian Trusts Act, 1882. Shareholders of ABC Ltd. and XYZ Ltd. call meeting of shareholders, creditors and pass special resolution. They submit copy of resolution to ROC, NCLT and publish in newspaper about successful arrangement. Few members of ABC Ltd. having 1.5% shares of valued ₹ 10 lakh objected to scheme of Acquisition by XYZ Ltd. ABC Ltd. Employee trust also objected to acquisition. NCLT cancelled the scheme citing grounds of unfair, unjust and objections of members having 1.5% shares in company. Based on above facts, answer the following with reasons quoting relevant provisions: Whether the compliance approvals given by the shareholders is sufficient for successful acquisition of product O business of ABC Ltd. Examine critically.
Answer & Explanation:
In the present case reduction of share capital, demerger, acquisition, notice to Competition Commission of India (CCI) for crossing threshold of asset/turnover, depository receipts attracting Reserve Bank of India (RBI) /Foreign Exchange Management Act (FEMA) & SEBI (SAST) Regulations, 2011 alongwith other sector regulator specific compliance issues are involved. Here both companies i.e., transferor and transferee will have to comply provisions of section 230 to 232 of Companies Act, 2013, SEBI (SAST) Regulations 2011, FEMA, Competition Act, approval of sector regulators (if product L, M, N and O need specific compliance issues to be ensured). Hence, mere submission of copy of resolution to ROC, NCLT and publishing in newspaper about successful arrangement will not suffice. NCLT will reject such application. Merger or amalgamation of companies involves various issues including the regulatory approvals. These regulatory approvals are to be obtained not only from the sector in which the company is operating (for example in case of merger of two banks, RBI's approval is needed) but also from other departments like Income Tax, SEBI, ROC, etc. The companies are required to obtain following approvals in respect of the scheme of amalgamation: (i) Authorisation Pre-approval authorisation about appointment of intermediaries, advisors, etc. Approval of Valuation Report by Audit Committee. (ii) Approval of Board of Directors Approval of scheme of amalgamation by the Board of both the companies. Board resolution should, besides approving the scheme, authorise a Director/Company Secretary/ other officer to make application to Tribunal, to sign the application and other documents and to do everything necessary or expedient in connection therewith, including changes in the scheme. (iii) Approval of Shareholders/Creditors, etc. Members' and creditors' approval to the scheme of amalgamation is sine qua non for Tribunal's sanction. This approval is to be obtained at specially convened meetings held as per Tribunal's directions [Section 230(1)]. However, the Tribunal may dispense with meetings of members/creditors [Section 230(9)]. (iv) Approval of the Stock Exchanges A listed entity desirous of undertaking a scheme of arrangement or involved in a scheme of arrangement, shall file the draft scheme of arrangement, proposed to be filed before Tribunal with the stock exchange(s). (v) Approval of Financial Institutions The approval of the Financial Institutions, trustees to the debenture holders and banks, investment corporations would be required if the Company has borrowed funds either as term loans, working capital requirements and/ or have issued debentures to the public and have appointed any one of them as trustees to the debenture holders. (vi) Approval from the Land Holders If the land on which the factory is situated is the lease-hold land and the terms of the lease deed so specifies, the approval from the lessor will be needed. (vii) Approval of the Tribunal Both companies (amalgamating as well as amalgamated) involved in a scheme of compromise or arrangement or reconstruction or amalgamation is required to seek approval of the respective Tribunal for sanctioning the scheme. Every amalgamation, except those, which involve sick industrial companies, requires sanction of Tribunal which has jurisdiction over the State/area where the registered office of a company is situated. If transferor and transferee companies are under the jurisdiction of different Tribunals, separate approvals are necessary. The notice of every application filed with the Tribunal has to be given to the Central Government (Regional Director, having jurisdiction of the State concerned). (viii) Approval of Reserve Bank of India Where the scheme of amalgamation envisages issue of shares/cash option to Non-Resident Indians, the amalgamated company is required to obtain the permission of Reserve Bank of India subject to conditions prescribed under the Regulations issued by RBI. (ix) Approvals from Competition Commission of India (CCI) The provisions relating to regulation of combination as provided under Sections 5 and 6 of the Competition Act, 2002 would also be required to be complied with by companies, if applicable.
Topics: Corporate Restructuring
Related Questions in this Topic
- Company A merges with Company B. The companies sign the agreement on January 1, 2026. The board decides to set the fi...
- StellarTech, a privately held company specializing in innovative battery technology for electric vehicles, has experienc...
- ABC Ltd. wanted to buy back its shares and provided the following information as on 31st March, 2026: 60,000 equity shar...
- X Ltd. makes a bid to purchase Company Y Ltd. Y Ltd. rejects the bid and thereafter used a strategy against X Ltd. to st...
- Restructuring aims at improving the competitive position of an individual business and maximizing its contribution to co...