The United Kingdom based Company BREXIT along with members of the Scotch Whisky Association (SWA) filed a suit before the Delhi High Court for permanent injunction to prevent the Defendant, Golden Bottling Ltd., an India

CS Professional · Intellectual Property Rights - Law and Practice · PYQS · June 2025
The United Kingdom based Company BREXIT along with members of the Scotch Whisky Association (SWA) filed a suit before the Delhi High Court for permanent injunction to prevent the Defendant, Golden Bottling Ltd., an Indian based company from selling whisky under the name "Red Scot" or any other similar designation incorporating the word "Scot", that creates misrepresentation with the genuine Scotch whisky. The SWA had previously many times appealed to the defendant from using the word 'Scot' or 'Scotch' in their whisky productions and dealings, for two years, the defendant dropped using the word Scot in their product, later on again it was found that the defendant was still selling Red Scot Whisky in the market. Therefore, the plaintiff filed a suit before the Delhi High Court. Subsequently, a summon was duly served accompanied by an injunction to prohibit the defendant from further using the word Red Scot or Scot. However, despite service of the summons, the defendant did not appear before the court. Consequently, the Court continued the proceedings ex parte against the defendant. The Delhi High Court in its final verdict provided a permanent injunction in favor of the plaintiff as they sought, and also ordered compensation amounting to Rupees Five Lakh along with litigation cost. In the light of the above case, answer the following questions: What is bio-piracy? Examine the impact of bio-piracy on bio-diversity.

Answer & Explanation:

Bio piracy is a violation of the rights of traditional communities over their biological resources and related knowledge. The implications of bio-piracy are economic as well as ethical: Obtaining IPRS usually patents or Plant Breeders Rights to gain monopoly control over biological resources, related traditional knowledge, or commercial products based on these resources or knowledge, without the consent of, or any benefits going to, the original holders of the resources/knowledge. The impact of bio-piracy on biodiversity are: Lack of Sustainability: Bio-piracy disregards the imperative of long-term sustainability, leading to the unchecked depletion of environmental resources. This short-sighted exploitation precipitates resource exhaustion and ecosystem collapse, engendering severe repercussions for both biodiversity and human welfare. Loss of Biodiversity: Bio-piracy often triggers the excessive exploitation of natural resources and the degradation of habitats, culminating in a decline in biodiversity. Such degradation profoundly affects ecosystems and the dependent species, leading to dire consequences. Disruption of Traditional Knowledge Systems: The illicit appropriation of traditional knowledge from indigenous communities disrupts their cultural heritage and ecological wisdom. This disruption not only undermines their way of life but also erodes invaluable traditional knowledge crucial for sustainable coexistence with nature. Genetic Erosion: Bio-piracy exacerbates genetic erosion by favouring the selective utilization of genetic resources beneficial for commercial ventures. This selective exploitation diminishes genetic diversity, compromising ecosystem resilience and rendering them susceptible to various threats like pests, diseases, and climatic fluctuations. Inequitable Distribution of Benefits: Bio-piracy entails the unjust exploitation of genetic materials and associated traditional knowledge, devoid of consent or compensation to the source communities. Such exploitation fosters social injustices and economic disparities, further marginalizing vulnerable communities.

Topics: Biodiversity

Open in Interactive Practice Hub · Full Practice Hub · Chapter Weightage · More in this subject

Related Questions in this Topic