A confectionery company VITA was launched in India in 1940 which owned many registered trademarks in India and abroad. The Company is particularly famous for its "Gluco" biscuit. With its unique color scheme and design o
CS Professional · Intellectual Property Rights - Law and Practice · PYQS · June 2025
A confectionery company VITA was launched in India in 1940 which owned many registered trademarks in India and abroad. The Company is particularly famous for its "Gluco" biscuit. With its unique color scheme and design of farmyard scene the wrapper was registered as a trademark in December 1942. This wrapper is used in connection with the sale of their biscuits known as "VITA Gluco Biscuits" printed on the wrapper. The wrapper is of blue color and depicts a farmyard with a girl in the center carrying a pail of water and cows and hens around her on the background of a farmyard house and trees. For decades, the company had been selling its biscuits in this iconic packaging, building a reputation and goodwill among customers as of which it became well known. However, in March 1961, they discovered that another company MTC was using a wrapper that they believed was deceptively similar to their registered trademark. VITA served a notice to prohibit the use of their wrapper but MTC, continued to use the wrapper. As a result, VITA filed a lawsuit seeking an injunction. MTC, in their defense, claimed they were unaware of the registered trademarks and denied that their wrapper was similar to the registered design. They argued that there were notable differences between the two wrappers. For instance, their design depicted a girl carrying a bundle of hay on her head and carrying a sickle and a bundle of food in one hand, the cow, and hens that were different from those in the other party's wrapper. There was also said to be a difference in the design of the buildings on the two wrappers and the words printed on the two wrappers were distinct and separate. In the light of the above facts, answer the following questions: Explain the concept of Trade Description under Trademark Law.
Answer & Explanation:
Trade description under Section 2(1)(za) of Trade Marks Act 1999, means any description, statement or other indication, direct or indirect: as to the number, quantity, measure, gauge or weight of any goods; or as to the standard of quality of any goods or services according to a classification commonly used or recognized in the trade; or as to fitness for the purpose, strength, performance or behaviour of any goods, being "drug", as defined in the Drugs and Cosmetics Act, 1940 or "food", as defined in the Prevention of Food Adulteration Act, 1954; or as to the place or country in which or the time at which any goods or services were made, produced or provided, as the case may be; or as to the name and address or other indication of the identity of the manufacturer or of the person providing the services or of the person for whom the goods are manufactured or services are provided; or as to the mode of manufacture or producing any goods or providing services; as to the material of which any goods are composed; or as to any goods being the subject of an existing patent, privilege or copyright, and includes- any description as to the use of any mark which according to the custom of the trade is commonly taken to be an indication of any of the above matters; the description as to any imported goods contained in any bill of entry or shipping bill; any other description which is likely to be misunderstood or mistaken for all or any of the said matters. As the name suggests, Trade Description briefly describes the service or product that a company or an individual is going to sell. The main aim of adding its description is to prevent retailers, manufacturers, or service providers from misleading customers. The registered trademark will provide the exclusive rights to its proprietor with respect to trade description provided in the application. However, different class covers various activities; the scope of protection provided by trademark will be limited only to the area defined by a trade description in trademark registration application. For example: If a company deals in the software industry with the brand name "PQR", another company may use the said brand name for a trade of other description like for legal industry or for sports purpose. Both these company can be registered under different class, but if the trade description does not match nature of work, then one cannot apply for registration. However, the discretion lies to accept the application with the Registrar itself. The approval for the trademark is circumstantial, and it depends on many other grounds. The Trade Marks Act gives power to the judiciary for punishing companies or individuals who make false claims about any products or services that they sell. The Section 104 of the Trade Marks Act, levies punishment on a person or a company who sells, or hire or exposes for sale, the product or service which gives any false impression of trademark or false trade description. The importance of filling true and correct trade description can be easily understood supported by famous case laws like 'Yahoo Inc. v. Akash Arora and another', 1999 Arb L. R. 620, 'P. Manikam v. Assistant Commissioner', 2017 (Madras High Court) etc.
Topics: Trademark Law
Related Questions in this Topic
- A confectionery company VITA was launched in India in 1940 which owned many registered trademarks in India and abroad. T...
- A confectionery company VITA was launched in India in 1940 which owned many registered trademarks in India and abroad. T...
- A Company named Ramsung manufacture Automobile under the name Roi Jaguar. The Ramsung Company is engaged in the manufact...
- A Company named Ramsung manufacture Automobile under the name Roi Jaguar. The Ramsung Company is engaged in the manufact...
- A Company named Ramsung manufacture Automobile under the name Roi Jaguar. The Ramsung Company is engaged in the manufact...