ABC Limited engaged in manufacturing of floor coverings has taken a Product Liability Insurance policy (PLI). Such a policy covers risk of liabilities for damages for bodily injury resulting from sale and distribution of
CS Professional · Internal and Forensic Audit · PYQS · December 2025
ABC Limited engaged in manufacturing of floor coverings has taken a Product Liability Insurance policy (PLI). Such a policy covers risk of liabilities for damages for bodily injury resulting from sale and distribution of floor coverings by vendors of ABC Limited's products. The policy is also subject to 'claim series' clause. A Claims Series event is a series of two or more claims arising from one specific common cause which are attributable to the same fault in design or manufacture of products or supply of the same products showing the same defect. A claim series event is deemed to be one claim under the terms and conditions of PLI policy. The company has been asked to shell out damages of ₹ 3 crores due to supply of faulty products to one of its vendors. The vendor had sold floor coverings to a 5-star hotel which has alleged that harmful chemicals used in dyeing of floor coverings have resulted in skin ailments to some of its guests. Being in capacity of Forensic Professional appointed by insurance company, what special issues would you keep in mind while dealing with claims involving PLI policy covering such matters ?
Answer & Explanation:
Special issues which the forensic professional should keep in mind while dealing with claims involving Product Linked insurance policy which cover losses arising from personal injury or property damage to a third party caused by a product the company designed, sold or supplied.: In claims involving product liability insurance policies, many documents are required from third parties. The third party may be unwilling to provide relevant documents to Forensic Professional concerning the very organization responsible for causing damages. Independence of Forensic Professional becomes paramount in such types of assignments because it involves engagement with parties who are not directly claiming from insurance company. Forensic Professional needs to resist any pressure or interference in establishing the scope of the assignments or the manner in which the work is conducted and reported. The company might be willing to negotiate it to salvage its reputation. It can lead to additional complexities. Quantification of legal liability under the policy can prove to be a challenging task and it has to be determined in accordance with policy terms & conditions. Careful analysis of date of loss when first claim occurred in accordance with 'claim series' clause and whether the same falls under the policy. Investigating the Claim's Validity: The primary role is to determine if the claim is legitimate, exaggerated, or fraudulent. This involves a thorough review of all circumstances surrounding the claim. Quantifying Economic Damages: The auditor calculates the actual financial loss suffered by the claimant due to the defective product. This often involves reviewing invoices, purchase orders, inventory records, and sales data to assess lost profits, repair costs, and other additional expenses. Gathering Evidence: They collect and analyze documentary and physical evidence in a manner that maintains a clear chain of custody, ensuring the evidence is admissible in court. Conducting Interviews: The auditor interviews the claimant, witnesses, employees, and other relevant parties to corroborate facts and identify inconsistencies in their statements. Analyzing Financial Records: They scrutinize financial statements, general ledgers, bank records, and tax returns for anomalies or patterns indicative of fraud or misstatement. Identifying Fraud Red Flags: The auditor is trained to spot signs of potential fraud, such as: Inconsistencies between reported damages and physical evidence. Claims filed shortly after increasing policy limits. Lack of supporting documentation (e.g., blank receipts or no store logos). The insured business or individual experiencing financial difficulties before the incident. Providing Litigation Support: If the case goes to court, the forensic auditor prepares detailed reports of their findings and can serve as an expert witness to explain complex financial matters to a judge and jury. Advising on Risk Mitigation: Based on their investigation, they may recommend improvements to internal controls and processes to prevent similar fraudulent activities or incidents from occurring in the future. Determining Subrogation Opportunities: In some cases, the auditor may identify opportunities for the insurer to recover losses from a third party (e.g., the original supplier of a faulty component).
Topics: Forensic Professional in Insurance Claims
Related Questions in this Topic
- As per Association of Certified Fraud Examiners (ACFE) 2022 report 85% of all fraudsters displayed at least one behaviou...
- The development of digital technologies has led to the growth of the internet, social media, and other digital platforms...
- The development of digital technologies has led to the growth of the internet, social media, and other digital platforms...
- The Bhartiya Sakshya Adhiniyam play an important role in determining the admissibility and weight of evidence in case in...
- Companies Act 2013, goes beyond professional liability for fraud and extends to personal liability if a company continue...